Public grocery store

Public grocery stores are grocery stores that are operated by a government for the benefit of the general public. Because these grocery stores are publicly owned and run for community benefit rather than solely for profit, the grocery stores have greater flexibility to lower prices for customers. While the term "public grocery store" is most commonly used to mean government-run grocery stores, cooperatives, non-profits, and public-private partnerships are also sometimes referred to as public grocery stores.[1] Government-owned grocery stores may be nationalized, tribally owned, municipality-owned, or owned by other sub-national jurisdictions. State-owned grocery stores have been common in current and historic communist and socialist states, but are also found in states with predominantly capitalist or mixed-market economies. Commissaries are grocery stores run by militaries or prisons to provide goods to enlistees and prisoners.[2][3]

About

The sociologist Justin Sean Myers and the psychologist Christine C. Caruso have compared government-run grocery stores for the general public to state-owned alcohol stores and military commissaries.[4]

The existence of public grocery stores alongside privately owned grocery stores in the context of a mixed-market economy has been referred to by some advocates as a "public option" for grocery shopping.[5][6]

Americas

Bolivia

The EMAPA supermarket chain in Bolivia is state-owned.[7]

Cuba

Most grocery stores in Cuba have been state-owned for decades, due to the government monopoly on retail. Some privately owned grocery stores are allowed to exist, but typically remain unaffordable for the majority of Cubans.[8]

Greenland

In some remote areas of Greenland, state-owned grocery stores provide food and other commodities imported from Denmark and other countries.[9]

United States

Each branch of the United States Armed Forces owns and operates its own public grocery system known as a PX or exchange, which is open to members of the military, and provides goods and services. The exchange includes military grocery stores known as commissaries.[10]

During the 21st century, several cities in the United States have operated city-owned grocery stores, including cities in Florida, Illinois, Kansas, and Wisconsin.[11] Many stores that have received subsidies have closed within a few years or failed to open.[12]

Some federally-recognized American Indian tribes operate their own grocery stores. The Citizen Potawatomi Nation and the Choctaw Nation own tribal grocery stores in Oklahoma.[13] The Citizen Potawatomi Nation's FireLake Foods in Shawnee, Oklahoma, is the largest tribal grocery store in the United States.[14]

In the 21st century, there has been a national movement supporting the establishment of grocery stores through public–private partnerships.[4]

Florida

Baldwin Market in Baldwin, Florida was owned and operated by the city. The grocery store was purchased by the city in 2019 and operated until March 2024, when it closed.[15]

Illinois

Launched in 2012, the Illinois Fresh Food Fund supported the opening of six grocery stores in food deserts.[16] Four of them have closed.[12]

In 2023, Rise Community Market opened in Cairo, Illinois.[17] In the first half of 2024, it averaged less than half its required sales to break even.[12]

City officials in Chicago have considered opening a city-owned grocery store, but instead opted to open multiple city-run markets throughout the city.[18][19]

In 2025, the city of Venice, Illinois announced a plan to build a city-owned grocery store.[20]

Kansas

In Kansas, several grocery stores are community-supported, municipality-owned, or city-run. In rural Kansas, local governments and communities had stepped in to own and operate grocery stores as private owners have retired. St. Paul Supermarket in St. Paul, Kansas, is a municipality-owned business.[21]

New York

Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic nominee for mayor of New York City in the 2025 election, has called for the creation of city-owned grocery stores in New York City.[22] Mamdani's proposal is to have a pilot program where 5 public grocery stores are opened, one in each borough.[23]

Wisconsin

Madison, Wisconsin has plans to open its first city-owned grocery store in a food desert on Madison's South Side, operated by Maurer’s Urban Market. Originally scheduled to open by the end of 2023,[24] the store is estimated to open in mid-2025.[25]

Venezuela

During the administration of Hugo Chávez, many supermarkets were nationalized in 2010.[26] These supermarkets were among his administration's more popular policies. Poor and low-income shoppers were more likely to frequent government-owned supermarkets, while wealthier shoppers more often frequented privately owned supermarkets.[27] When oil prices collapsed during the administration of Chávez's successor Nicolás Maduro, state-owned supermarkets struggled to import food during the economic crisis.[28]

The Bicentenario supermarket chain in Venezuela was formerly owned by the state.[29] Nationalized under the administration of Hugo Chávez, the chain was later reprivatized.[30]

Asia

Iran

The discount supermarket and department store chain Shahrvand Chain Stores Inc. is owned by the city government of Tehran.[31]

Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka has a government-owned supermarket chain known as Lanka Sathosa.[32] As of 2015, it was Sri Lanka's only state-owned supermarket chain.[33]

Vietnam

Vietnam's socialist government maintains state-owned supermarkets.[34]

Europe

Belarus

According to a 2005 United Nations Commission on Human Rights report, state-owned supermarkets in Belarus engaged in censorship by refusing to sell independent newspapers.[35]

Bulgaria

Due to the government monopoly on retail, grocery stores were government-owned in the communist People's Republic of Bulgaria.

In 2025, the Bulgarian government announced that it would be opening a chain of state-owned supermarkets.[36]

Czech Republic

Due to the state monopoly on retail, all grocery stores were government-owned in socialist Czechoslovakia and consolidated together under a single grocery store network called Zdroj. Zdroj owned grocery stores, greengrocers, and butcher shops across the Czech Socialist Republic. The basis of Zdroj was a grocery store chain privately owned by Julius Meinl, Jedlo Bratislava, and Lahôdky Lamplota that was nationalized in 1948. Following the collapse of socialism, Zdroj was broken up into several regional chains and privatized.[37][38]

Aside from Zdroj, Czechoslovakia also had a network of consumer cooperatives called Jednota that sold food products.[37]

Hungary

Due to the state monopoly on retail in the socialist Hungarian People's Republic, grocery stores were owned by the Hungarian government.

The state-owned Csemege grocery chain was established in 1952. In 1992, following the collapse of the socialist government, Csemege was privatized and sold to the Austrian retail company Julius Meinl. Csemege-Julius Meinl was later purchased by the Belgian Louis Delhaize Group and incorporated into the supermarket chain Match.[39][40] Julius Meinl also purchased the privatized Közért supermarket chain.[41]

The state-owned Duna Fuszert Rt supermarket chain was privatized in 1989 when it was sold to the Belgian privately owned corporation Louis Delhaize Group. In 1991, the group purchased several more privatized small grocery stores and renamed them Profi.[42]

In 1992, the CBA supermarket chain was formed by 10 businessmen who purchased 17 privatized grocery stores.[42]

In 1995, the state-owned Global supermarket chain was privatized. 45 former Global supermarkets were purchased by Tesco.[43][44]

Poland

Due to the nationalization of retail in the socialist Polish People's Republic, many Polish grocery stores were state-owned. Społem, a consumers' co-operative of local grocery stores, was also under state ownership.[45]

Romania

State-owned grocery stores were once common in the Socialist Republic of Romania. The state monopoly on retail ended after the collapse of Communism in 1989.[46]

Russia

Grocery stores and department stores were state-owned during the Soviet era. Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, many grocery stores and other retail outlets were privatized.

The Eliseyevsky grocery store in Moscow was state-owned during the Soviet era. The store was privatized in the early 1990s.[47]

Serbia

Due to the government monopoly on retail, grocery stores were government-owned in communist Yugoslavia.

The C-market supermarket chain was state-owned in Yugoslavia and Serbia and Montenegro.[48] The first Serbian supermarket was a C-market opened in Belgrade in 1958.[49]

Slovakia

Due to the state monopoly on retail, all grocery stores were government-owned in socialist Czechoslovakia and consolidated together under a single grocery store network called Zdroj. Zdroj owned grocery stores, greengrocers, and butcher shops across the Slovak Socialist Republic. The basis of Zdroj was a grocery store chain privately owned by Julius Meinl, Jedlo Bratislava, and Lahôdky Lamplota that was nationalized in 1948. Following the collapse of socialism, Zdroj was broken up into several regional chains and privatized.[38][37]

Aside from Zdroj, Czechoslovakia also had a network of consumer cooperatives called Jednota that sold food products.[37]

Slovenia

Slovenia is an ex-Yugoslavian republic. As such, its economy was largely state-owned prior to the dissolution of the federation. The state still owns many enterprises, such as the banks, which in turn own businesses such as supermarkets and newspapers.[50]

Spain

In 2023, in response to rising grocery store prices, the Spanish left-wing political party Podemos has proposed the creation of government-owned supermarkets with reduced prices.[51]

Oceania

New Zealand

There are no state-owned grocery stores in New Zealand. State-owned supermarkets have been debated as a possible answer to New Zealand's "supermarket duopoly", but no proposal has been enacted.[52] The two privately owned supermarket chains, Foodstuffs and Woolworths New Zealand, together maintain a 90% market share in New Zealand.[53][54]

Criticism

Criticism of government-owned grocery stores has come from private business owners, including bodega owners. The organization United Bodegas of America and John Catsimatidis, a billionaire owner of a supermarket chain, have criticized public grocery stores as harmful to private businesses and their workers.[55]

See also

References

  1. ^ "Public Grocery Stores: A Guide for Policymakers" (PDF). Vanderbilt University. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  2. ^ "Commissaries and Exchanges". Military OneSource. Retrieved 2025-07-09. Commissaries are basically your neighborhood grocery store, located on military installations worldwide. The commissary sells food and household items at prices that are often below other grocery stores.
  3. ^ "Commissary". Indiana Department of Correction. 3 June 2024. Retrieved 2025-07-09. Commissary is a store within a correctional facility where incarcerated individuals can purchase various goods and supplies. These items often include snacks, hygiene products, and clothing.
  4. ^ a b "Towards a public food infrastructure: Closing the food gap through state-run grocery stores" (PDF). Geoforum. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  5. ^ "Is It Time for a Public Option for Groceries?". The Progressive. 23 June 2025. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  6. ^ "America Has Plenty of Experience With Government-Run Stores, and It Isn't Pretty". Reason.com. 27 June 2025. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  7. ^ "Bolivia emerges from severe crisis and returns to growth of 9.4%". The Rio Times. 23 November 2021. Retrieved 2025-07-02.
  8. ^ "Cuban Private Grocery Stores Thrive, But Few Can Afford Them". Voice of America. 19 November 2023. Retrieved 2025-07-05.
  9. ^ Hayashi, Naotaka; Delaney, Alyne E. (September 2024). "Climate change, community well-being, and consumption: Reconsidering human-environment relationships in Greenland under global change". Polar Science. 41 101102. Bibcode:2024PolSc..4101102H. doi:10.1016/j.polar.2024.101102.
  10. ^ "Why New Yorkers Voted For Public Grocery Stores: Explained". Forbes. Retrieved 2025-07-05.
  11. ^ "Zohran Mamdani wants to build government supermarkets. America already has them". CNN. Retrieved 2025-07-01.
  12. ^ a b c "The Government Spends Millions to Open Grocery Stores in Food Deserts. The Real Test Is Their Survival". ProPublica. 9 August 2024. Retrieved 2025-07-08.
  13. ^ "Tribal-operated grocery stores provide jobs, low prices, fresh food". The Journal Record. 23 January 2019. Retrieved 2025-07-06.
  14. ^ "Native American-Owned FireLake Foods Aims To Be Community Partner". The Shelby Report. 31 October 2023. Retrieved 2025-07-06.
  15. ^ "Baldwin's unusual town-owned and operated grocery store is coming to a close in March". The Florida Times-Union. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  16. ^ "Illinois Fresh Food Fund generates $34 million in community investment". 15 October 2018. Retrieved 2025-07-08.
  17. ^ "Coalition brings desperately needed grocery store to Illinois' southernmost city". University of Illinois System. Retrieved 2025-07-08.
  18. ^ "Chicago's plan to establish city-owned grocery store revised in favor of public markets". WBEZ. 12 February 2025. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  19. ^ "Chicago says it hopes to open city-owned market instead of city-owned grocery store". Chicago Tribune. 11 February 2025. Retrieved 2025-06-30.
  20. ^ "Venice gets $2.4M state grant for much-needed grocery store to anchor redevelopment". NPR. 15 May 2025. Retrieved 2025-07-01.
  21. ^ "St. Paul Supermarket" (PDF). RuralGrocery.org. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  22. ^ "What are Zohran Mamdani's policies? Where he stands on rent, city-owned stores, more". USA Today. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  23. ^ "Mamdani is promising government-run grocery stores. How would that work?". The Week. Retrieved 2025-07-07.
  24. ^ "Madison's nears opening of first municipally owned grocery store". Madison Commons. 16 February 2024. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  25. ^ "Promise kept: City of Madison secures lease for Maurer's Market on S. Park St". City of Madison. 18 November 2024. Retrieved 2025-07-09.
  26. ^ "Special Report: Asset Nationalization". Global Finance. 6 June 2012. Retrieved 2025-07-11.
  27. ^ "Retail Food Sector" (PDF). Foreign Agricultural Service. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  28. ^ Ellsworth, Brian (9 June 2016). "Shortage-plagued Venezuela puts socialist committees in charge of selling food". Reuters. Reuters. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  29. ^ Hernandez, Rigoberto (27 February 2015). "#NPRreads: A Sign Of The Times? Trinidad Offers Venezuela Toilet Paper For Oil". NPR. NPR. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  30. ^ "Workers' Control in Venezuela Faces an Uncertain Future". MENAFN. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  31. ^ Becker, Jo (23 December 2010). "U.S. Approved Business With Blacklisted Nations". The New York Times. Retrieved 2025-07-07.
  32. ^ "Sri Lanka to retain public ownership of Lanka Sathosa". Lanka Business Online. 26 May 2017. Retrieved 2025-07-05.
  33. ^ "Singapore offers to help LAKSATHOSA revival". Daily FT. Retrieved 2025-07-05.
  34. ^ "Pioneering innovation: the story of state-owned supermarkets". Vietnam+. 8 October 2024. Retrieved 2025-07-02.
  35. ^ Severin, Adrian (16 January 2006). Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in Belarus, Adrian Severin (Report). United Nations Commission on Human Rights.
  36. ^ "State-owned supermarket chain launches in Bulgaria – with only local products, low margins". Trade Magazin. 21 March 2025. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  37. ^ a b c d "Central and Eastern Europe: Impact of Food Retail Investments on the Food Chain" (PDF). Integrated Food Security Phase Classification. Retrieved 2025-07-09.
  38. ^ a b "History Talks: The communist grocery store Zdroj". The Slovak Spectator. Retrieved 2025-07-09.
  39. ^ Mayer, Charles S.; Bakhshandeh, Reza M. (11 April 2015). "Global Vs. Local-The Hungarian Retail Wars". Journal of Business and Retail Management Research. 10 (1). doi:10.24052/JBRMR/210 (inactive 12 July 2025).{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of July 2025 (link)
  40. ^ "Selling State Companies to Strategic Investors" (PDF). World Bank Group. Retrieved 2025-07-10.
  41. ^ "The History of European Integration" (PDF). Masaryk University. Retrieved 2025-07-11.
  42. ^ a b "Global Vs. Local-The Hungarian Retail Wars" (PDF). Journal of Business and Retail Management Research. Retrieved 2025-07-11.
  43. ^ Tiusanen, Tauno (2006). Foreign Investors in Transitional Economies: Cases in Manufacturing and Services (Report).
  44. ^ "TESCO PLANNING 20 UNITS IN HUNGARY". Supermarket News. Retrieved 2025-07-11.
  45. ^ "A Dream Forgotten" (PDF). Polish Academy of Sciences. Retrieved 2025-07-06.
  46. ^ "Romanian government reintroduces state-owned grocery stores 3 decades after the collapse of former communist-age trade monopoly". Business Review. 29 July 2019. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  47. ^ Weir, Fred (9 April 2021). "When is a grocery store not a grocery store? When it's a palace". Christian Science Monitor.
  48. ^ "YUGOSLAV ECONOMY HURTING, BUT SO FAR NO ONE IS STARVING". Chicago Tribune. 20 April 1999. Retrieved 2025-07-04.
  49. ^ "The consumer basket". Museum of Yugoslavia. Retrieved 2025-07-05.
  50. ^ "Saved a state bailout, Slovenes question hefty banking bill". tribunedigital-chicagotribune. 16 December 2013. Retrieved 5 July 2025.
  51. ^ "Publicly-owned supermarkets? Left-wing party sparks debate in Spain as food prices soar". Euronews. Retrieved 2025-07-11.
  52. ^ "Christopher Luxon won't say if coalition partners would back breaking up supermarkets". Radio New Zealand. 31 March 2025. Retrieved 2025-06-29.
  53. ^ "Shopping for change: Busting the supermarket duopoly". RNZ. 2022-07-15. Retrieved 2025-07-11.
  54. ^ "Stop waiting for a foreign hero: NZ's supermarket sector needs competition from within". University of Sydney. Retrieved 2025-07-11.
  55. ^ "Critics take aim at Zohran Mamdani's plan for NYC-run grocery stores". WNBC. Retrieved 2025-07-11.